Medicare Advantage · Ohio · 2026 plan year

Medicare Advantage in Pickaway, OH

According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) 2026 Landscape and Star Ratings files, every Medicare Advantage plan available in Pickaway, OH for 2026 is ranked by CMS star rating, with premiums and benefits laid out plainly.

81
Plans available
4.5★
Best plan: Top-rated
$0
Lowest premium/mo
$25.22
Avg premium/mo
RSS updates for this county

The short answer

Pickaway has 81 Medicare Advantage plans for 2026, the best earns 4.5★ from CMS, 50 reach 4★ or higher, and 27 carry a $0 monthly premium.

81
plans to compare
4.5★
highest CMS rating here
27
$0-premium plans
50
plans rated 4★ or higher

Premiums shown are the monthly plan premium (Part C + D). Every enrollee also pays the standard Part B premium (about $202.90/mo in 2026). Confirm any plan's current details on Medicare.gov before enrolling.

What the CMS Plan Finder Shows for Pickaway, OH

Pickaway, OH (FIPS 39129): 81 individual Medicare Advantage plans available (employer-group plans excluded). Highest CMS Star rating: 4.5/5 via SIERRA HEALTH AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, INC.. Plan-type mix: 33 HMO, 30 Local PPO, 18 HMO POS. Monthly plan premiums (Part C + D) range $0 – $149.00 (avg $25.22), with 27 $0-premium plans. 77 of 81 plans include Part D drug coverage. CMS Star Ratings methodology →

How to read these figures

The figures above come from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services 2026 plan year file, which CMS publishes each autumn before the October 15 to December 7 open enrollment window. A county premium reflects only the Part C portion that a plan charges. Most enrollees still pay the standard Part B premium of about $202.90 a month on top of it, so a $0 plan is rarely free in practice. The CMS star rating runs from one to five and weights more than 40 measures, including how well a plan manages chronic conditions, how fast it answers member calls, and how members rate their own care. A plan that holds five stars earns a special enrollment period that lets people switch into it at almost any time of year. Premiums alone can mislead a shopper, because a low monthly cost often pairs with a higher deductible or a tighter provider network. Federal rules cap in-network out-of-pocket spending at $9,250 for 2026, which is why two plans with identical premiums can leave very different bills after a hospital stay. Read our methodology for how each value here is sourced and computed.

Where Pickaway sits on CMS quality

Average CMS star rating across the plans sold in this county, against every county with rated plans

3.9★ Top 27% higher than 73% of 3,121 US counties

2.5★–2.75★: 19 US counties (1%). Below this entry. 2.75★–3★: 5 US counties (0%). Below this entry. 3★–3.25★: 31 US counties (1%). Below this entry. 3.25★–3.5★: 164 US counties (5%). Below this entry. 3.5★–3.75★: 1,089 US counties (35%). Below this entry. 3.75★–4★: 1,344 US counties (43%). This entry sits in this band. 4★–4.25★: 351 US counties (11%). Above this entry. 4.25★–4.5★: 37 US counties (1%). Above this entry. 4.5★–4.75★: 3 US counties (0%). Above this entry. 4.75★–5★: 78 US counties (2%). Above this entry. This county 2.5★ 5★ every rated county, bucketed by value

Each bar is a band; taller bars hold more US counties. The dashed line + filled bar mark this entry. Hover or tap any bar for its full count, share, and where it sits relative to this entry.

Source CMS Medicare Advantage Star Ratings 2026 · 2026-09-01

All plans in Pickaway, ranked by CMS rating

#PlanInsurerTypePremium/moCMS stars
1Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)MediGoldHMO-4.5★
2Aetna Life Insurance Company (SNP)Aetna MedicareLocal PPO-4.5★
3Emphesys Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO-4.5★
4Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)MediGoldHMO$04.5★
5Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)MediGoldHMO$04.5★
6Aetna Life Insurance Company (SNP)Aetna MedicareLocal PPO$04.5★
7Emphesys Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$04.5★
8Emphesys Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$04.5★
9Emphesys Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$04.5★
10Sierra Health AND Life Insurance Company, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareLocal PPO$31.404.5★
11Caresource Ohio, Inc. (SNP)CareSource MyCare Ohio (HMO D-SNP)HMO$31.404.5★
12Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)MediGoldHMO$34.004.5★
13Medical Mutual OF Ohio (SNP)Medical Mutual of OhioLocal PPO$44.004.5★
14Medical Mutual OF Ohio (SNP)Medical Mutual of OhioLocal PPO$73.004.5★
15Mount Carmel Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)MediGoldHMO$102.004.5★
16Medical Mutual OF Ohio (SNP)Medical Mutual of OhioLocal PPO$149.004.5★
17Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio Inc (SNP)Devoted HealthLocal PPO-4.0★
18Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. (SNP)Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldLocal PPO-4.0★
19Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO POS$04.0★
20Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO$04.0★
21Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio Inc (SNP)Devoted HealthLocal PPO$04.0★
22Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio Inc (SNP)Devoted HealthLocal PPO$04.0★
23Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$04.0★
24Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$04.0★
25Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$04.0★
26Community Insurance Company (SNP)Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldHMO POS$04.0★
27Unitedhealthcare OF Wisconsin, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$04.0★
28Unitedhealthcare OF Wisconsin, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$04.0★
29Unitedhealthcare OF Wisconsin, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$04.0★
30Unitedhealthcare OF Wisconsin, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$04.0★
31Medical Mutual OF Ohio (SNP)Medical Mutual of OhioHMO$04.0★
32Mount Carmel Health Insurance Company (SNP)MediGoldLocal PPO$14.004.0★
33Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO$17.204.0★
34Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO$17.904.0★
35Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO$28.704.0★
36Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO$31.404.0★
37TSG Guard, Inc. (SNP)Valor Health PlanHMO$31.404.0★
38Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$31.404.0★
39Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$31.404.0★
40Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$31.404.0★
41Devoted Health Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Devoted HealthHMO$31.404.0★
42Community Insurance Company (SNP)Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldHMO POS$31.404.0★
43Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$31.404.0★
44Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$31.404.0★
45Medical Mutual OF Ohio (SNP)Medical Mutual of OhioHMO$45.004.0★
46Unitedhealthcare OF Wisconsin, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$49.004.0★
47Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. (SNP)Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldLocal PPO$51.004.0★
48Aetna Health OF Ohio Inc. (SNP)Aetna MedicareHMO POS$52.004.0★
49Unitedhealthcare OF Wisconsin, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareHMO POS$76.004.0★
50Medical Mutual OF Ohio (SNP)Medical Mutual of OhioHMO$94.004.0★
51THE Health Plan OF West Virginia, Inc. (SNP)The Health PlanHMO-3.5★
52Humana Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO-3.5★
53Humana Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO-3.5★
54Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareLocal PPO-3.5★
55THE Health Plan OF West Virginia, Inc. (SNP)The Health PlanHMO$03.5★
56Humana Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$03.5★
57Humana Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$03.5★
58Humana Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$03.5★
59Humana WI Health Organization Insurance Corp (SNP)HumanaHMO POS$03.5★
60Humana WI Health Organization Insurance Corp (SNP)HumanaHMO$03.5★
61THP Insurance Company (SNP)The Health PlanLocal PPO$03.5★
62Humana WI Health Organization Insurance Corp (SNP)HumanaHMO$4.603.5★
63Humana WI Health Organization Insurance Corp (SNP)HumanaHMO$16.003.5★
64Humana WI Health Organization Insurance Corp (SNP)HumanaHMO$17.403.5★
65THE Health Plan OF West Virginia, Inc. (SNP)The Health PlanHMO$17.703.5★
66Humana Insurance Company (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$21.003.5★
67Humana Benefit Plan OF Illinois, Inc. (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$27.003.5★
68Humana Benefit Plan OF Illinois, Inc. (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$31.403.5★
69Humana Benefit Plan OF Illinois, Inc. (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$31.403.5★
70Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Co. (SNP)UnitedHealthcareLocal PPO$59.003.5★
71Humana Benefit Plan OF Illinois, Inc. (SNP)HumanaLocal PPO$85.003.5★
72THP Insurance Company (SNP)The Health PlanLocal PPO$109.003.5★
73Buckeye Community Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)Wellcare By AllwellHMO POS$03.0★
74Molina Healthcare OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)Molina Healthcare of OhioHMO$19.603.0★
75Buckeye Community Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)Wellcare By AllwellHMO POS$27.403.0★
76Buckeye Community Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)Wellcare By AllwellHMO POS$30.103.0★
77Buckeye Community Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)Wellcare By AllwellHMO POS$31.403.0★
78Community Insurance Company (SNP)Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldHMO$7.10N/R
79Community Insurance Company (SNP)Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldHMO$25.70N/R
80Unitedhealthcare Community Plan OF Ohio, Inc. (SNP)UnitedHealthcare Community PlanHMO POS$31.40N/R
81Buckeye Community Health Plan, Inc. (SNP)WellcareHMO$31.40N/R

Nationwide counties with similar Medicare Advantage markets

Data-derived peers across the CMS county landscape file: nearest enrollable plan count and nearest county-wide average CMS star rating. Not same-state neighbors or geographic containment.

Similar plan availability

Similar average CMS star rating

Choosing a plan in this county

Star rating first, then total cost, not the premium alone.

  • Shortlist the 4★+ plans above (50 here) - higher-rated plans manage chronic care and member service better. How star ratings work
  • Weigh total cost, not just premium: compare plan details using Medicare.gov before you enroll. Medicare Plan Compare
  • Check that your doctors and drugs are in-network before you enroll, and confirm the plan on Medicare.gov. Choosing a plan

Premiums shown are the monthly plan premium (Part C + D) from the CMS CY2026 Landscape file. Every enrollee also pays the standard Part B premium (about $202.90/mo in 2026). Always confirm current premiums, copays, and networks on Medicare.gov before enrolling.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many Medicare Advantage plans are available in Pickaway, OH?

There are 81 Medicare Advantage plans available in Pickaway, OH for the 2026 plan year, including 33 HMO, 30 Local PPO, 18 HMO POS. Counts are individual consumer plans (employer-group / EGHP offerings excluded). Plan availability is determined by CMS and individual insurers.

What is the best-rated Medicare Advantage plan in Pickaway?

The highest-rated plan in Pickaway has a CMS star rating of 4.5 out of 5 - SIERRA HEALTH AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, INC.. Star ratings reflect quality measures including preventive care, chronic disease management, and member satisfaction.

How much do Medicare Advantage plans cost in Pickaway?

Monthly plan premiums (Part C + D combined) in Pickaway range from $0 to $149.00, averaging $25.22. 27 plans offer a $0 monthly premium. Every enrollee also pays the standard Part B premium (about $202.90/month in 2026) on top of the plan premium. Premiums are from the CMS CY2026 Landscape file; always confirm current details on Medicare.gov.

What types of Medicare Advantage plans are offered in Pickaway?

Pickaway has 33 HMO, 30 Local PPO, 18 HMO POS. HMO plans require in-network providers, PPO plans allow out-of-network visits at higher cost, and PFFS plans let you see any Medicare-accepting provider.

Important: PlainMedicare provides CMS data for informational purposes only. This is not medical or insurance advice. Plan availability, premiums, and benefits change annually. Always verify with Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE before enrolling.
Data sourced from official public datasets. See our methodology for details. Retrieved and formatted by PlainMedicare